Practical guide

How a CHRO can build the case for applied AI capability evidence

A chief human resources officer should not have to approve an abstract promise that “AI training will improve productivity.” A defensible business case names the work decision, the affected population, the evidence gap, the smallest useful intervention, the cost and risk boundary, and the evidence that will determine whether to continue.

By Two Prune

A chief human resources officer should not have to approve an abstract promise that “AI training will improve productivity.” A defensible business case names the work decision, the affected population, the evidence gap, the smallest useful intervention, the cost and risk boundary, and the evidence that will determine whether to continue.

Use the CASE method

Use the CASE method: Connect to a priority workflow, Audit the current evidence gap, Stage a bounded assessment pilot, and Evaluate decision value. The CHRO may own the people strategy, influence governance, collaborate with business and technology leaders, or review the evidence. The method does not presume that every CHRO owns the technology budget or every operational decision.

C — Connect the case to a priority workflow

Start with a workflow where AI is already changing tasks or where leaders must decide whether broader use is appropriate. Avoid beginning with a company-wide skill label.

Document:

CIPD’s current guidance treats AI skills planning as part of staged organizational adoption and asks people leaders to connect capability planning to real work, governance, employee involvement, and changing roles. It also cautions against treating early interest as mastery. That provides a current first-party basis for starting with adoption stage and workflow context, while each organization must establish its own priorities and evidence. CIPD AI skills planning guidance

  • the business decision and accountable operational owner;
  • the workflow, deliverable, users, systems, and material constraints;
  • what people currently do with and without AI;
  • the failure modes that matter to customers, employees, or the organization;
  • the capability evidence currently available;
  • the action leaders cannot take confidently because that evidence is missing.

Sources: [1]

A — Audit the evidence gap

Separate four layers that are often merged in a weak business case.

| Evidence layer | Question | Typical source | What it cannot establish alone | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | access | can the person reach approved tools and materials? | entitlement and environment records | capable use | | activity | did the person attend, complete, or use something? | learning and product logs | performance in realistic work | | applied capability | what did the person do with evidence, AI, verification, and judgment? | structured work simulation and reviewed deliverable | transfer to the live workflow | | operational outcome | did quality, time, risk, or service change? | workflow and business measures | cause without a suitable design |

Inventory missingness and participation. Record who was eligible, invited, started, completed, unable to participate, or excluded from analysis. Do not turn non-participation into a low capability result. Review whether access, workload, location, language, disability accommodation, manager support, or tool approval affects who can demonstrate performance.

The U.S. Department of Labor’s AI principles for developers and employers emphasize worker input, transparency, human oversight, training, rights, job quality, and protection of worker data. These are bounded government principles, not a compliance determination, but they support making participation, oversight, and data protection explicit in the business case. U.S. Department of Labor AI best practices

Sources: [2]

S — Stage a bounded assessment pilot

The pilot should resolve a decision, not merely produce a score distribution.

### Define the pilot contract

Two Prune is an assessment product. It can provide structured evidence from realistic AI-enabled work simulations. It is not an applicant tracking system, does not make employment decisions, and should not be positioned as proof of productivity or future job performance.

### Cost the pilot honestly

Include platform and implementation cost, scenario design, source preparation, participant time, reviewer time, calibration, accommodations, data governance, analysis, and follow-up. State which costs are one-time and which recur. Do not compare this complete cost with a training price that excludes participant time or operational support.

List alternatives: manager observation, work samples, knowledge quizzes, vendor certifications, self-report, learning completion, and existing quality metrics. Explain what each alternative can and cannot answer. The case for an assessment is strongest when leaders need comparable evidence of applied performance in a controlled workflow—not because every adjacent signal is worthless.

  • Decision: for example, whether finance-planning teams need workflow redesign, verification practice, or targeted learning before broader AI use.
  • Population: named teams and eligibility rule, with voluntary or required participation stated clearly.
  • Assessment task: a realistic work simulation with synthetic or authorized materials, a business deliverable, and observable use of evidence and AI.
  • Evidence: final output plus process signals relevant to context framing, evidence navigation, AI orchestration, verification and risk control, judgment and synthesis, and communication and delivery.
  • Reviewer and scoring controls: rubric version, calibration procedure, missing-evidence rule, challenge path, and confidence limitation.
  • Data boundary: collection, access, retention, approved uses, prohibited uses, and deletion route.
  • Decision rule: the evidence pattern that leads to a learning intervention, workflow repair, deeper review, or no action.
  • Stop rule: conditions such as material access inequity, unusable evidence, unreliable scoring, or a changed business workflow.

E — Evaluate decision value

Define the decision record before the pilot starts.

| Gate | Evidence required | Decision owner | Continue when | Hold or change when | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | participation | eligibility, start, completion, and missingness by relevant group | people programme owner | access is workable and gaps are understood | barriers make results unrepresentative | | evidence quality | complete submissions, process evidence, source access, reviewer notes | assessment owner | evidence supports the intended construct | missingness or leakage undermines interpretation | | scoring | rubric fit, calibration, disagreement, confidence notes | qualified review owner | scores are usable for the bounded decision | reviewer disagreement or construct mismatch persists | | actionability | named intervention tied to observed evidence | operational owner | the result changes a real plan | report produces only generic recommendations | | transfer | later workflow measure and follow-up evidence | workflow owner | improvement is observed with stated limits | no usable measure or major confound exists |

Report counts and denominators. Keep descriptive pilot results separate from validated benchmarks. If a change follows the pilot, avoid causal claims unless the evaluation design supports them. A business case may be successful because it prevents an unsupported rollout, reveals a workflow defect, or identifies missing evidence—not only because scores rise.

Worked business case: finance-planning verification

A synthetic organization wants to give 120 finance staff a broad generative-AI course. Ninety-one percent of an earlier cohort completed an online module, and tool telemetry shows 82% monthly use. Leaders still see inconsistent source checking in management packs, but the anecdotal evidence cannot identify whether the problem is access, work design, capability, or review practice.

The CHRO collaborates with the CFO and information-security lead on a 36-person pilot across three planning teams. Participants complete a synthetic variance-analysis simulation using a workbook, policy excerpt, and conflicting manager request. The assessment records how they frame the decision, inspect sources, use AI, recalculate material figures, manage unsupported claims, and deliver an executive note. The pilot excludes live employee-performance decisions and uses synthetic data.

Thirty-four people complete. The evidence shows that most participants can produce a clear narrative, while a smaller pattern of weak source reconciliation appears across all three teams. Two participants could not access the approved AI environment; their sessions are recorded as incomplete rather than low performance. Reviewer calibration identifies one ambiguous rubric criterion, which is revised and rescored before reporting.

The decision is not “buy more training because the average score was 68.” The CFO owns a source-reconciliation checkpoint in the live workflow; the people team commissions targeted practice on verification; the technology team repairs access; and the assessment owner schedules a bounded reassessment. Any later quality change is evaluated using the operational review process, with other changes and sample limits disclosed.

Executive one-page artifact

Use these nine fields:

The strongest case is modest and testable. It funds evidence for a named decision, protects participants from over-interpretation, and makes it possible to stop when the evidence is not good enough.

  • priority workflow and business decision;
  • accountable owner and CHRO role;
  • current evidence and the unresolved gap;
  • alternatives considered and why they are insufficient for this decision;
  • pilot population, task, and participation safeguards;
  • assessment evidence, scoring, confidence, and challenge route;
  • complete cost, risks, and data boundary;
  • pre-agreed continue, change, and stop gates;
  • follow-up decision and evidence date.