Practical guide

How a Chief AI Officer can build the case for applied AI capability evidence

A Chief AI Officer should build the business case around a decision the organization cannot make well today, then test whether better capability evidence changes that decision. The case is not “buy an assessment because AI matters.” It is a bounded argument connecting an operating decision, its current evidence gap, a small pilot, explicit safeguards, and a stop-or-scale rule.

By Two Prune

A Chief AI Officer should build the business case around a decision the organization cannot make well today, then test whether better capability evidence changes that decision. The case is not “buy an assessment because AI matters.” It is a bounded argument connecting an operating decision, its current evidence gap, a small pilot, explicit safeguards, and a stop-or-scale rule.

Bound the role before the investment

Chief AI Officer mandates vary. OMB Memorandum M-25-21 offers one current public-sector example: federal agencies are directed to empower accountable officials, maintain AI use-case inventories, develop policy, coordinate governance, and manage high-impact uses. It is a source for possible responsibilities, not a universal private-sector job description. OMB Memorandum M-25-21

Classify the Chief AI Officer for the proposed decision as one or more of:

Name the finance owner, business owner, people or learning owner, risk and privacy reviewers, and programme operator separately. Do not imply that the Chief AI Officer automatically controls every budget, participant decision, or workforce outcome.

  • Owner: accountable for the portfolio decision and its result.
  • Influencer: shapes the case but another executive owns funding or workforce policy.
  • Reviewer: checks governance, evidence quality, security, or measurement design.
  • Collaborator: supplies platforms, data, programme support, or operational context.

Sources: [1]

Build a CASE business case

CASE turns a broad capability claim into a testable decision packet.

### C — Context and costly decision

Choose one recurring decision such as where to place enablement support, whether a workflow pilot is ready to expand, or which control weakness needs remediation. Record the affected workflow, population boundary, decision owner, current evidence, cost of error, and review date.

Do not start with a score. Start with the decision and ask what evidence would be sufficient to change it.

### A — Alternatives and counterfactual

Compare at least three routes: keep the current process, improve existing surveys or usage analytics, run work-sample assessments, or combine them. For each route, record what it observes, what it misses, operating burden, data risk, latency, and the decision it can support.

Tool access, usage volume, self-reported confidence, manager impressions, and observed work performance are different constructs. None should be relabelled as capability merely because it is easy to count.

### S — Signals, safeguards, and interpretation

Define the evidence packet before the pilot. A realistic work assessment may provide the submitted artifact, source use, verification behaviour, AI interaction, revision history, rubric evidence, score confidence, and calibration notes. Specify missing-data rules, reviewer access, retention, appeal or correction path, and prohibited interpretations.

NIST’s AI RMF Core calls for documented roles, risk priorities, monitoring, accountability, and lifecycle management. GAO’s AI Accountability Framework organizes practices around governance, data, performance, and monitoring. These frameworks support disciplined evidence design; adopting them does not prove that a particular assessment, programme, or control is effective. NIST AI RMF Core and GAO AI Accountability Framework

### E — Experiment and executive gate

Pre-register a small pilot with a named population, realistic tasks, baseline comparison, quality review, decision deadline, and scale criteria. Include negative outcomes that would stop the initiative: unusable evidence, excessive burden, weak inter-reviewer consistency, privacy or security failure, participant confusion, or no material change in the target decision.

The executive gate should choose scale, repair, narrow, or stop. “Continue learning” is not a substitute for a decision unless it has a deadline and owner.

Sources: [2] [3]

Copyable decision-and-evidence map

| Decision | Current evidence | Critical gap | Proposed evidence | Owner | Safeguard | Pilot success condition | Stop condition | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | expand an AI-enabled workflow | access logs, completion counts, manager anecdotes | no direct evidence of source checking or error handling | realistic task, work artifact, observed process, calibrated review | business owner | consent, minimization, access limits, correction route | evidence is usable and changes a defined support decision | evidence is unreliable, burdensome, unsafe, or immaterial |

Add cost ranges rather than a single invented ROI number. Separate one-time design, operational review, participant time, platform, integration, governance, and remediation costs. Record which values are observed, quoted, estimated, or unknown.

Worked example: a finance workflow pilot

The following is synthetic and demonstrates the method rather than a product outcome.

A company has given 120 finance staff access to an approved AI assistant. Usage is rising, but leaders cannot tell whether staff verify source data before distributing management commentary. The Chief AI Officer is the portfolio influencer and governance reviewer; the finance transformation leader owns the workflow decision; learning operations runs the pilot; privacy and security review the evidence design.

The current route—usage analytics plus a confidence survey—shows availability and self-report, not whether participants catch a conflicting source number. The proposed pilot invites 24 volunteers from the bounded workflow to complete a synthetic variance-analysis assessment. The task includes a spreadsheet with one inconsistent total and a memo with an outdated assumption. Reviewers examine the final artifact and observed checking behaviour using a defined rubric.

The scale gate requires that evidence is complete enough for the support decision, reviewer disagreements are resolved through a documented process, participants understand the boundary, and the finance owner can name a specific enablement change. The stop gate triggers if sensitive operational data is needed, evidence cannot distinguish verification from presentation polish, or the result would be used as an employment recommendation. All counts and conditions here are illustrative.

Answer the predictable objections

“We already have adoption analytics.” Use them for access and usage questions. Add work evidence only when the decision depends on what people do inside a task.

“Managers already know their teams.” Manager observations can add context, but they may be uneven and difficult to reproduce. Test whether a common task and rubric adds decision-relevant evidence rather than assuming it does.

“One score will simplify reporting.” A single score can hide missing evidence, uncertainty, and different failure modes. Report observed evidence, pillar-level interpretation, confidence, and limitations alongside any summary.

“We need an ROI forecast.” State the causal chain and uncertainties. Do not convert assumed time savings, assessment scores, or pilot participation into proven financial outcomes.

Reporting boundary

Report the target decision, population, task, evidence completeness, observed patterns, reviewer process, uncertainty, costs, incidents, and gate decision. Keep access, adoption, capability, control operation, and business results in separate lines. A positive assessment signal does not establish productivity, legal compliance, safety, or organizational performance.

Two Prune is an assessment product for realistic AI-enabled work simulations. It can help customers collect and explain observed assessment evidence. It is not an ATS, hiring recommendation system, or substitute for accountable executive, legal, security, privacy, or professional judgment.

Sources

Office of Management and Budget: M-25-21, Accelerating Federal Use of AI through Innovation, Governance, and Public Trust

  • National Institute of Standards and Technology: AI Risk Management Framework Core
  • U.S. Government Accountability Office: Artificial Intelligence Accountability Framework for Federal Agencies and Other Entities

Sources: [1] [2] [3]

Sources

  1. 1.OMB Memorandum M-25-21 · www.whitehouse.gov
  2. 2.NIST AI RMF Core · National Institute of Standards and Technology
  3. 3.GAO AI Accountability Framework · U.S. Government Accountability Office