Practical guide

AI capability pilot design for a Chief AI Officer

A useful AI capability pilot gives a Chief AI Officer a bounded decision, not a showcase. It should reveal whether people can perform a consequential workflow with AI, where evidence breaks down, which safeguards operate, and what would justify scaling, redesigning, or stopping. The Chief AI Officer may own, sponsor, review, or coordinate the pilot depending on the organization. Do not assume.

By Two Prune

A useful AI capability pilot gives a Chief AI Officer a bounded decision, not a showcase. It should reveal whether people can perform a consequential workflow with AI, where evidence breaks down, which safeguards operate, and what would justify scaling, redesigning, or stopping. The Chief AI Officer may own, sponsor, review, or coordinate the pilot depending on the organization. Do not assume the title always carries budget authority or sole accountability.

Define the decision before choosing participants

Write one decision the pilot must support. For example: “Should we expand an AI-assisted monthly variance-explanation workflow from one finance team to three teams?” Then record the decision date, executive owner, workflow owner, risk reviewers, affected people, available alternatives, and what happens if evidence remains inconclusive.

OMB Memorandum M-25-21 provides a current public-sector example of a Chief AI Officer mandate: federal agency CAIOs promote AI innovation, adoption, and governance; coordinate with responsible officials; and advise agency leadership. This is a bounded federal example, not a universal private-sector job description. OMB Memorandum M-25-21

Sources: [1]

Use the PROBE pilot method

PROBE separates workflow evidence from adoption theatre.

### P — Problem and comparison

Select one recurring, material workflow with a real quality standard and a reviewable output. Describe its current process, failure cost, cycle time, evidence sources, handoffs, and control points. Compare at least three options: current process, process improvement without generative AI, and the proposed AI-assisted design. A pilot should not win merely because the alternative was never measured.

### R — Roles and risk boundary

Name the executive decision owner, workflow owner, participant, reviewer, data owner, security or privacy reviewer, and person authorized to pause the pilot. Define allowed tools, source systems, information classes, prohibited uses, escalation routes, and the decision that must remain human.

NIST’s AI Risk Management Framework Core calls for documented roles, executive responsibility, defined human oversight, monitoring, and contextual evaluation. Use those outcomes to design the pilot’s accountability boundary; do not treat framework alignment as proof that the workflow is safe or effective. NIST AI RMF Core

### O — Observable capability tasks

Build representative tasks that require more than tool access. Participants should frame an ambiguous request, locate relevant evidence, use AI in an inspectable way, detect a planted inconsistency, verify numerical and source claims, revise their work, and deliver a decision-ready artifact. Preserve both the output and the evidence of how it was produced.

Do not use a single easy task or self-reported confidence as the capability measure. Distinguish access, activity, adoption, observed capability, control operation, and business outcome.

### B — Baseline, blind test, and breakdowns

Record the current workflow baseline before the pilot. Include quality defects, review effort, cycle time, exception rate, and rework where they can be measured consistently. Add a designed challenge that a superficial AI workflow is likely to miss: a conflicting source, stale policy, changed assumption, ambiguous authority, or calculation trap.

Predefine breakdown categories such as unsupported claim, missed evidence, wrong source version, calculation error, overreliance, confidentiality breach, weak escalation, or unusable communication. Capture missing evidence as missing; do not convert it into poor performance.

### E — Exit evidence and decision gate

Set scale, repair, hold, and stop conditions before results are known. A scale gate might require acceptable output quality across representative tasks, successful detection of critical contradictions, operating review controls, no unresolved high-severity incidents, and a credible resource case. A stop gate might include prohibited data use, repeated unsupported claims, inability to reproduce decisions, or review effort that exceeds the baseline.

The GAO AI Accountability Framework organizes accountability practices around governance, data, performance, and monitoring and supplies questions for managers and assessors. Those principles support a multi-source pilot record rather than a one-number success claim. GAO AI Accountability Framework

Sources: [2] [3]

Copyable pilot decision map

| Decision | Current option | AI-assisted option | Evidence needed | Method | Owner | Scale gate | Stop gate | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | expand / repair / hold / stop | baseline workflow and cost | bounded workflow and safeguards | output, process, controls, exceptions, resources | representative tasks plus review | named decision and workflow owners | pre-registered condition | pre-registered condition |

Keep a separate evidence register for task version, participant context, source set, tool configuration, observed workflow events, deliverable, reviewer findings, exceptions, incident response, and uncertainty. Usage counts belong in that register but cannot stand in for capability or outcome.

Worked example: finance variance explanations

This example is synthetic. A finance team spends substantial review time turning ledger extracts, budget notes, and manager comments into monthly variance explanations. The CAIO sponsors a six-week pilot with the controller as workflow owner, finance participants, an information-security reviewer, and an executive committee as the scale decision maker.

The current process and a redesigned non-AI template form the comparison. Each participant receives the same bounded source pack and must produce an explanation with calculations, citations, unresolved questions, and recommended follow-up. One source pack contains a later manager note that contradicts the first explanation for a large variance.

Access telemetry shows nearly every participant used the AI tool. That is adoption evidence only. The assessment evidence separates participants who found and resolved the contradiction from those who repeated the earlier explanation. Reviewers recalculate the material figures, check source anchors, and score the decision artifact against a predeclared rubric. The pilot also records reviewer minutes, rework, prohibited-data incidents, and unresolved exceptions.

The synthetic results show faster first drafts but inconsistent contradiction handling and no reduction in final review effort. The pre-registered scale gate is therefore not met. The decision is repair, not “successful adoption”: redesign the source-check step, clarify escalation, run a new challenge task, and retest before expanding. No invented ROI is reported.

Reporting packet for the CAIO

The final packet should contain:

Report distributions and failure patterns rather than hiding variation in a single average. Separate observed task performance from claims about team productivity, business value, or organization-wide capability.

  • the decision and comparison options;
  • participant and task sampling rationale;
  • baseline definitions and known measurement gaps;
  • observed output, process, and control evidence;
  • critical failures, exceptions, and missing data;
  • resources required for the next stage;
  • scale, repair, hold, or stop disposition with named owners;
  • the next evidence gate and review date.

Hold conditions and claims boundary

Hold the pilot when there is no real decision, no baseline, no accountable workflow owner, an unapproved data route, an unreviewable AI configuration, insufficient task realism, an absent critical control, or a scale decision that will be made regardless of the evidence. Stop immediately for prohibited data exposure or an uncontrolled high-severity consequence.

Two Prune can provide realistic AI-enabled work simulations and evidence-backed assessment records for a bounded pilot. It does not prove organization-wide productivity, certify compliance, establish safe AI use, or make employment decisions. Any business-outcome claim requires separate operational evidence and an appropriate comparison.

Sources

Office of Management and Budget: M-25-21, Accelerating Federal Use of AI through Innovation, Governance, and Public Trust

  • National Institute of Standards and Technology: AI Risk Management Framework Core
  • U.S. Government Accountability Office: Artificial Intelligence Accountability Framework

Sources: [1] [2] [3]

Sources

  1. 1.OMB Memorandum M-25-21 · www.whitehouse.gov
  2. 2.NIST AI RMF Core · National Institute of Standards and Technology
  3. 3.GAO AI Accountability Framework · U.S. Government Accountability Office