Practical guide

AI negotiation plan verification checklist

A negotiation plan should not be released because it looks polished. It should be released only when another reviewer can trace the mandate, evidence, calculations, boundaries, approvals, and remaining uncertainty. Use this checklist after the plan has been drafted and before it is used in a supplier or customer conversation. This is a verification artifact, not another method for writing the.

By Two Prune

A negotiation plan should not be released because it looks polished. It should be released only when another reviewer can trace the mandate, evidence, calculations, boundaries, approvals, and remaining uncertainty. Use this checklist after the plan has been drafted and before it is used in a supplier or customer conversation. This is a verification artifact, not another method for writing the plan. It returns one of three dispositions for every check: pass, repair, or not evidenced. A critical repair or not-evidenced result stops release.

Use the CLEAR review

Run the checks in five passes. Record the evidence location and reviewer note rather than ticking a box from memory.

### C — Confirm mandate and decision rights

Critical stop: an unapproved walk-away boundary, missing decision maker, or unclear authority to commit.

### L — Link parameters to evidence

The World Bank's negotiation guidance treats preparation as a structured process involving objectives, parameters, risk, authority, and a negotiation plan. That supports a traceable evidence register; it does not determine the right commercial answer for a particular negotiation.

### E — Exercise packages and boundaries

Local Partnerships recommends treating price as only one part of supplier negotiation and considering whole-life cost, quality, risk, and deliverability. The checklist therefore tests the complete package rather than optimizing one visible number.

### A — Audit approvals and communication controls

The UK Small Business Commissioner's guidance advises businesses to understand their position, prepare terms, ask questions, and keep records. Those practices make a review reproducible; they do not replace professional commercial or legal review.

### R — Record disposition and residual uncertainty

  • Name the negotiation owner, decision maker, subject-matter reviewers, and person permitted to approve a change.
  • State the commercial objective, the minimum acceptable outcome, and the conditions that require a pause or escalation.
  • Verify that every walk-away boundary is approved and dated. Do not infer authority from an earlier contract or an informal message.
  • Separate facts, internal preferences, working assumptions, and proposals that have not been offered.
  • Confirm who may communicate a concession and whether a second approval is required.
  • Give each important parameter an evidence reference: current agreement, invoice, usage record, supplier quote, benchmark, policy, or approved internal constraint.
  • Record source date, owner, unit, currency, tax treatment, and any relevant population or time window.
  • Recalculate totals, percentages, volume tiers, and multi-year effects from the cited inputs.
  • Mark stale, partial, disputed, or inaccessible sources instead of silently treating them as current.
  • Trace every factual claim in the negotiation brief to a source or label it as an assumption.
  • Test the base proposal, a credible counterproposal, and at least one adverse case.
  • Check that a concession is conditional: what is given, what is received, who can authorize it, and how it changes the overall package.
  • Compare packages on the same units and time horizon. Include implementation, termination, support, and transition effects when material.
  • Test for contradictions between the executive brief, issue list, package table, and contract language.
  • Identify a pause condition for new information, an unexpected participant, or a request outside the mandate.
  • Attach or link the current approval record for the objective, boundaries, and proposed packages.
  • Confirm that sensitive internal limits are separated from material intended to be shared externally.
  • Ensure notes distinguish an exploratory statement from an agreed term.
  • Verify that any AI-produced calculations, summaries, or clause comparisons were checked against the source material.
  • Name the note taker and the system of record for decisions, actions, and revised wording.
  • Assign pass, repair, or not evidenced to every row.
  • Describe each repair, owner, due date, and evidence required to close it.
  • State residual uncertainty that remains after repair and who accepts it.
  • Re-run affected calculations and contradiction checks after any material change.
  • Date the final disposition and retain the reviewed version of the plan.

Downloadable checklist

Copy this table into the plan record or spreadsheet. Add rows when a negotiation has additional regulated, technical, security, or operational constraints.

| ID | Verification question | Evidence reference | Result | Repair / residual uncertainty | Owner | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | C1 | Are decision rights and approval thresholds explicit? | | | | | | C2 | Are objective, minimum outcome, and pause conditions approved? | | | | | | L1 | Does every material parameter trace to a dated source? | | | | | | L2 | Were totals, tiers, percentages, and term effects recalculated? | | | | | | E1 | Were the base, counter, and adverse packages tested consistently? | | | | | | E2 | Is each concession conditional and within authority? | | | | | | E3 | Do the brief, package table, and proposed terms agree? | | | | | | A1 | Are approvals current and sensitive limits access-controlled? | | | | | | A2 | Were AI-assisted claims and calculations checked against sources? | | | | | | R1 | Are repairs, owners, due dates, and closure evidence recorded? | | | | | | R2 | Is residual uncertainty explicit and accepted by the right owner? | | | | |

Worked verification: analytics renewal

A synthetic team is preparing to renew an analytics subscription. The draft plan targets a 12% price reduction, offers a three-year term, and says the supplier's support response is below market.

The CLEAR review finds five defects:

The reviewer records do not release. After the approvals, calculation, claim, and conditional concession are repaired, affected rows are retested. The final record still notes uncertainty about year-three usage; the package includes a documented review point rather than disguising the uncertainty as precision.

  • C2 — repair: the plan uses a walk-away total of £180,000, but the finance approval covers only the target price. The owner must obtain approval for the boundary before release.
  • L1 — not evidenced: the “below market” support claim cites a two-year-old blog post, not a comparable current source. The claim is removed until a suitable source is recorded.
  • L2 — repair: a volume tier is applied to all three years although expected seats decline in year three. Recalculation changes the package comparison.
  • E2 — critical repair: the three-year commitment is offered without a reciprocal price cap or service term. It is rewritten as a conditional exchange and routed for approval.
  • C1 — critical repair: the operational lead can recommend but cannot approve a term extension. The commercial director is added as decision maker.

What this checklist can and cannot establish

A completed checklist shows that a specific plan was reviewed against recorded criteria. It does not show that the other party will accept the proposal, that the commercial outcome will be favourable, or that every legal, tax, procurement, security, or regulatory issue has been resolved. Add specialist review where the agreement requires it.

Two Prune is an assessment product. It can place a participant in a realistic work simulation and capture evidence of how they frame, research, calculate, verify, and communicate a negotiation plan. It does not negotiate on a customer's behalf, approve a live agreement, provide legal or financial advice, forecast later workplace performance, or make employment decisions.

Primary sources

World Bank, Procurement Guidance: Negotiation and Best and Final Offer

  • UK Small Business Commissioner, How to negotiate terms and conditions
  • Local Partnerships, Supplier negotiations

Sources: [1] [2] [3]